In any Florida custody case, the guiding principle that courts use to determine custody arrangements is the “best interest of the child” standard. This standard ensures that all decisions made regarding custody and parental responsibility prioritize the child’s well-being, stability, and overall development.
If you are navigating a custody case in Florida, you must understand what the courts are looking for to ensure your best possible outcome. The experienced Tampa custody lawyers at Melone Hatley, P.C. are here to stand by you as a trusted partner during life’s most difficult times. Our goal is to provide personalized legal solutions and advocacy, protecting your and your children’s rights and well-being throughout your custody case.
What Does “Best Interest of the Child Mean?”
The “best interest of the child” standard is a legal framework used by most family law courts today, including Florida, to evaluate what custody arrangements will most benefit a child’s physical, emotional, and psychological needs. This standard prioritizes the child’s safety and security in custody determinations and their ability to maintain a healthy relationship with both parents whenever possible.
However, custody determinations weren’t always made this way. Historically, family courts relied on the Tender Years Doctrine, which presumed that young children, particularly those under five, should remain in the care of their mothers. This doctrine was widely used for decades, but today, Florida law explicitly states that no presumption exists favoring one parent over the other, ensuring a more fair and balanced approach to custody decisions.
Schedule your free meeting with our team today to see if our Lawyers can help you.
The Importance of Access to Both Parents in Custody Decisions
Florida courts recognize that, in most cases, a child benefits from maintaining a strong relationship with both parents. Studies have consistently shown that children with access to both parents have better emotional, psychological, and academic outcomes. Consequently, courts generally aim for shared parental responsibility when making custody decisions unless there are compelling reasons to limit one parent’s involvement.
Although some parents believe sole custody is their best option, Florida law strongly favors co-parenting and emphasizes that children should have “frequent and continuing contact with both parents” unless there is clear and convincing evidence that this would be harmful to the child. Findings show that children who have a consistent and loving relationship with both parents tend to
- Develop stronger emotional and psychological stability
- Have better behavioral and academic outcomes
- Develop stronger family bonds
- Have a more balanced upbringing
That being said, even when a custody arrangement aims for shared parental responsibility, there is usually a primary custodial parent and a noncustodial parent in a typical custody arrangement.
The primary custodial parent is the one with whom the child lives the majority of the time and is responsible for their day-to-day care. The noncustodial parent, on the other hand, typically has scheduled parenting time and is often responsible for child support payments. Determining these roles is when the court must consider what is in the best interest of the child.
What Factors Does the Court Consider When Determining What is in the Child’s Best Interest?
Under Florida Statute § 61.13, the court will consider the following factors when making custody decisions.
The ability of each parent to provide for the child’s needs
The court will assess each parent’s ability to provide food, clothing, medical care, education, and other necessities for the child’s care. Parents who demonstrate stability in providing for their child’s daily needs are usually viewed more favorably by the court.
The child’s emotional and developmental needs
Courts will evaluate which parent can best meet their child’s emotional and developmental requirements, including supporting their schooling, extracurricular activities, and their mental well-being.
The stability of each parent’s home environment
Household stability is crucial for a child’s well-being post-divorce. Courts favor a setting that provides structure, routine, and minimal disruptions for the child.
Each parent’s ability to provide consistent routines
Because daily routines regarding school, homework, bedtime, and other daily activities are considered important to a child’s development, the court will consider this when making custody decisions.
The mental and physical health of each parent
Both parents’ mental and physical health play a critical role in their ability to care for their child. The court may evaluate medical or psychological issues that could interfere with a parent’s responsibilities.
The willingness of each parent to support the child’s relationship with the other parent
Because Florida courts emphasize co-parenting, the court will assess each parent’s willingness to encourage a meaningful relationship between the child and the other parent. When one parent tries to alienate the child from the other, the court considers this negative behavior when making custody decisions.
The moral fitness of each parent
The court will consider a parent’s behavior, such as substance abuse, criminal activity, or exposing the child to inappropriate situations, and whether it could negatively impact the child.
The parent’s involvement in the child’s life
A parent who has historically been involved in their child’s upbringing, including attending school events, extracurricular activities, and doctor appointments, may be viewed as more capable of providing continuity in the child’s life.
Evidence of domestic violence, abuse, or neglect
If there is a history of domestic violence, abuse, or neglect, the court will prioritize the child’s safety in custody decisions and may limit or restrict the abusive parent’s custody or visitation rights.
Click to contact our family lawyers today
What is the Role of Status Quo in Florida Custody Decisions?
In Florida custody determinations, the court will usually consider the “status quo” — the current and historical parenting arrangement before the custody case was filed. Courts generally favor maintaining stability in the child’s life, and the parent who has been the primary caregiver for an extended period will often have the advantage in a custody case.
While the status quo is not the sole deciding factor in these decisions, it carries significant weight when the court wants to maintain consistency and stability for the child. Unless there is a compelling reason to change the existing arrangement, the court will often seek to preserve a child’s routine as much as possible.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today
As the Needs and “Best Interests” of the Child Change, Can Custody Be Modified?
Children’s educational, medical, emotional, and social needs will shift as they grow and mature. However, custody modifications in Florida are not granted lightly.
The court will require compelling evidence that a custody modification is necessary to support a change in the child’s needs. If so, the court may consider granting a modification if it can be proven it is in the child’s best interests.
Other situations that may warrant a custody modification include:
- A parent’s relocation
If a parent moves a significant distance away, an existing custody and visitation schedule may no longer be practical. Under Florida law, a parent who wants to relocate more than 50 miles away for more than 60 days must seek court approval when it affects the current parenting plan. - A parent’s change in circumstances
If a parent has lost a job, remarried, or experienced a significant lifestyle change that impacts their ability to care for the child, the court may consider a custody modification. - Evidence of abuse, neglect, or endangerment
If a parent can prove the other parent has engaged in harmful behavior that impacts the child’s welfare, such as domestic violence, substance abuse, or neglect, the court may agree to a custody modification to protect the child. - Parental interference with the current arrangement
When one parent deliberately interferes with the other’s time sharing or fails to comply with the existing parenting plan, the court may modify the existing custody order to ensure the child has meaningful contact with both parents. - The child’s preference
While Florida does not have a specific age at which a child can choose which parent to live with, the court may consider an older child’s wishes if they are mature enough to express a reasonable preference.
The bottom line is that custody arrangements can be modified when there is a substantial change in circumstances and the proposed modification is in the best interest of the child. Even if both parents agree to a change of custody, court approval is required to be legally binding and enforceable.
Understanding the “Best Interest of the Child” Standard When You are Pursuing a Florida Child Custody Case
Child custody is one of the most emotionally charged and legally complex issues a parent can face, and understanding the “best interest of the child” standard is essential for any parent navigating a custody case in Florida. Whether you are negotiating a parenting plan or litigating a custody matter in court, presenting evidence demonstrating your ability to provide a loving, stable, safe, and supportive environment will be key to achieving a favorable custody outcome.
When navigating a custody matter, having experienced legal guidance will be essential to protect your rights and ensure the best outcome for you and your child. At Melone Hatley, P.C., our experienced Tampa child custody attorneys are committed to advocating for your and your child’s best interests. We provide compassionate and strategic legal counsel tailored to your unique situation, helping you navigate the process with confidence. Don’t face this challenging time alone.Contact us today or call (813) 400 1602 to schedule a free consultation with one of our Client Services Coordinators.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today.
