If you are going through divorce, you know it is challenging. When one or both spouses are military service members, there are additional legal complexities. While civilian divorces are regulated by individual state law, federal and international laws often intersect with state law in a military divorce.
What are the Hogue Cases?
The Hogue cases refer to a series of legal decisions addressing the division of military retirement and disability benefits for military spouses navigating divorce.
Overall, the Hogue cases have played a critical role in protecting the legal and financial interests of divorcing military service members and their spouses by providing a legal framework for the division of military retirement and disability benefits, ensuring well-defined rights and fair treatment for both spouses.
Schedule your free meeting with our team today to see if our Lawyers can help you.
How Have the Hogue Cases Impacted Today’s Military Divorce Laws?
In military family law, “Hogue case” generally refers to legal decisions established in the Hogue v. Hogue cases and legal precedent set by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Hogue v. Secretary of Health and Human Services (1991).
Collectively, the Hogue cases have shaped the legal landscape of military retirement and disability benefits division in the context of a divorce and addressed challenges involved when one or both spouses is overseas.
The following are some key takeaways on how Hogue cases have impacted military divorce law.
The Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act (USFSPA)
The Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act is a federal law providing certain benefits to former spouses of military service members. Under the USFSPA, a former spouse of a military service member can be entitled to portions of the military member’s retirement pay, medical care, and exchange and commissary benefits.
The USFSPA grants state courts the right to consider “disposable military retirement pay” marital property to be divided under state property division laws. It also provides guidelines for how benefits get divided in a divorce when one or both parties are overseas.
Clarifies Division of Military Retirement Pay and Disability Benefits During Divorce
The Hogue cases further clarify that military retirement benefits earned during a couple’s marriage are considered marital property and divisible according to state laws, similar to civilian retirement benefits.
However, under the Hogue decisions, there is a differentiation between regular military retirement pay and disability retirement pay. The Hogue cases established that disability benefits are intended solely for the service member’s benefit, are considered separate property, and are not subject to property division in a divorce.
Reinforces Preemption of Federal Law Over State Law Regarding Disability Benefits
The Hogue cases have further reinforced that federal law would preempt state law regarding the division of military disability benefits during a divorce.
Addresses Jurisdictional Challenges
Because legal jurisdiction is essential in a divorce setting and can be complicated when one or both parties are stationed overseas, Hogue cases have provided clarity and consistency, emphasizing that state courts must properly establish a service member’s permanent domicile when determining which court will have jurisdiction.
Service of process and enforcement of court orders can also be particularly complicated when one party is overseas. Understanding military law and international enforcement methods and coordinating with military authorities will be critical for divorcing military service members, their spouses, and their legal counsel.
Reinforces the Need For Spouses to be Aware of Their Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) Entitlement
The military allows Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) coverage for former spouses. The Hogue cases have underscored the need for spouses to be aware of this entitlement which would provide them continued income in the event of the service member’s death.
Establishes Legal Precedent
The ruling in Hogue v. Secretary of Health and Human Services established legal precedent and has become foundational in military family law. This precedent has guided both military family lawyers and the courts when handling military divorce cases.
Navigating the Unique Challenges of a Military Divorce
The Hogue decisions and principles have clarified how military retirement benefits differ and how they must be divided in a divorce situation. They have also emphasized the need for precise understanding and handling of overseas situations, ensuring that both individuals are protected and court orders enforceable.
Military divorces are subject to unique federal laws and jurisdictional challenges beyond those of civilian divorces. A military divorce lawyer must have an in-depth knowledge and understanding of military regulations and the legal system of the country where a service member is stationed.
At Melone Hatley, P.C., our highly experienced military divorce attorneys stand ready to be your staunchest partners and allies, ensuring your legal rights are protected. With offices throughout Virginia, Charlotte, NC, and Tampa, FL, we have an extensive understanding of military and international divorce law and how it can affect your case. Schedule a free consultation through our website contact form, or call us at (800) 479-8124.
Schedule a call with one of our client services coordinators today.
